Summary & Additional Remarks by Geopolist | Istanbul Center for Geopolitics:
Giorgia Meloni is at a crossroads. As Italy’s Prime Minister, she has spent the past two years carefully balancing her relationships with both the European Union and the United States. But now, with Donald Trump back in the White House and tensions rising between Washington and Europe over Ukraine, she’s facing a tough decision—one that could define not only her leadership but Italy’s place in the world.
Meloni has worked hard to position herself as a trusted ally of Washington, even being the only EU leader invited to Trump’s inauguration in 2025. She’s played the game well, presenting herself as a pragmatic leader who can talk to both the far-right and the global establishment. At home, she leans into her image as a self-made, working mother who challenges the old, male-dominated political order. Internationally, she reassures allies that Italy is still a stable European power. But her balancing act is becoming increasingly difficult.
When Trump and Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky had a public falling-out, most European leaders didn’t hesitate to side with Zelensky. Meloni, however, stayed quiet. She understands the stakes. Siding with Trump might solidify her position as his closest European partner, but it would also make her look weak in the eyes of her European counterparts—leaders like Emmanuel Macron and Germany’s Olaf Scholz, who are pushing for a stronger, more unified Europe. Meanwhile, in Italy, her coalition partner Matteo Salvini has openly embraced Trump, hoping to win over voters who are frustrated with the ongoing war in Ukraine.
The problem is, Italy’s challenges run deeper than just foreign policy. The country is drowning in debt—136% of its GDP, the second highest in the EU. Economic growth is slow, hovering around 0.7% in 2024, and much of that is propped up by EU funding that won’t last forever. The Italian economy, long struggling to keep up with its European peers, faces an even tougher road ahead as an aging population increases the strain on pensions and healthcare. If Italy wants to keep itself afloat, it needs European investment and stability—something that Meloni can’t afford to gamble with by alienating Brussels.
And then there’s defense. Italy has been lagging behind on military spending for years, falling well below NATO’s 2% of GDP target. Compared to France, Germany, and the UK, Italy’s diplomatic reach and security capabilities are limited, making it harder to have a real impact on global affairs. Trump’s return to power is likely to put even more pressure on allies to contribute more to defense, and Italy might not be able to keep dodging the issue for much longer.
Meloni’s close relationship with Trump may offer short-term benefits—perhaps better trade deals or less pressure on defense spending—but it won’t fix Italy’s long-term problems. Historically, Italy has relied on the European Union and NATO to maintain its influence on the world stage. If Meloni shifts too far in Trump’s direction, she risks isolating Italy from the very institutions that have helped it stay relevant.
European leaders are watching closely. Macron has already made it clear that he wants Italy to stand firmly with France and Germany as part of a united European front. His message is clear: Italy can’t afford to play both sides forever. The time will come when Meloni will have to make a choice.
And that choice won’t just be about foreign policy—it will be about what kind of leader she wants to be. Will she be the European leader who bridges the gap between the EU and the U.S., helping keep the alliance together? Or will she fully embrace Trump’s nationalist, America-first agenda, even if it means weakening Europe’s unity? It’s not just about Meloni’s political future; it’s about Italy’s place in the world. And time is running out for her to decide.
Read more below.
